50 icons: monthlyinspo round 14 + others

[neonspider]

Fandoms:
Doctor Who [7+2]
Farscape [6+1]
Supernatural [5+1]
Teen Wolf [3+1]
Buffy the Vampire Slayer [2+1]
Dorian Gray [2+1]
Once Upon a Time [2+1]
Sherlock [2]
Breaking Bad, Once Upon a Time in Wonderland, The Rocky Horror Picture Show, Star Trek (2009), X-Men [1+1 alt each]
Atonement, Free!, LOST [1 each]

This is my set for round 14 at monthlyinspo! The theme was Film Noir, so I decided to create my first and probably only fully b&w 20in20 set ever. I'm so used to relying on vibrant colors that I wanted to see if my icons are any good without them. There are some other elements here that were also inspired by the theme but I don't think I've ever seen a noir film, so I might be way off with my take on it, but this is where my inspiration went from the challenge post :>

Since this is so different for me, I'd really appreaciate any feedback! I included the colored alts for the ones that have them (since some of these started as color icons), and I'd be very interested in hearing which ones look better in b&w and which do you like more in color?
I also included a LOT of extras, cause I made a ton and had a hard time choosing which ones to select for the actual set. I hope you can take a look at those as well and tell me if I left out something I should have selected!

Hover for fandoms :)

MONTHLYINSPO ROUND 14

[01-05]
[06-10]
[11-15]
[16-20]


COLOR ALTS

[21-25]
[26-30]


OTHERS
(31-36 were made for your_favourites, the others were cut from monthlyinspo)
[31-35]
[36-40]
[41-45]
[46-50]

Feel free to snag any you like, credit is optional, comments much appreciated ♥

Comments

[sietepecados]

These look amazing! I love the crop on 8 and 17 - so dramatic. Also your text work here looks so great - 1, 3, 16 and 18 are just perfect. I also love the coloring on 28 and 44.

[xafirah.livejournal.com]

The "noir" set is amazing! And so are the alts and all other icons :)
The text use, comporitions, b&w contrast are just perfect!

[vanessa-lj.livejournal.com]

These are amazing, a true masterpiece! I can not decide if I like more B & W or colored, in both the theme Noir is perfectly made and I'm in love with 23 and 35: D

[lady_turner]

You literally mastered the b&w technique: these icons are to die for! ♥
Favourites are 2, 3, 5, 6, 10, 12, 14, 15, 18, 22, 32, 37 and 50!

[rosy-nic.livejournal.com]

Great icons :)

[hughville.livejournal.com]

Lovely, lovely icons! I love the contrast in the black and white ones and the unique coloring and textures in the others.

[thyla87.livejournal.com]

WOW!!! Absolutely amazing!! The composition your FilmNoir set is spectacular and so powerful :) I love your b&w set and the lighting; OMG!! ♥ The way you use grunge is so beautiful and fantastic! I love how creative you are and you always do some new :)

1 has magnificent lighting and grunge style :)
10, 2, 3 has fantastic and so creative blending and I love text of 3!
The crop of 8 and 17 is glorious!! And the contrast is just WOW!!
I just adore your text style ♥ 10 and 11 has so amazing text and different style/font and they are all balance!
18 has so cool silhouette , text and contrast!
The lighting of 20 is captivating!!! :)

Of course I love the color version but I think that b&w are so fantastic and I am very happy that you decide to make all b&w! 22, 23, 26, 28 are my fave for the colors. Also I really love 32, 33, 36, 40, 41, 43, 46, 50!! ♥

I will take some, will credit!

[arbdhax.livejournal.com]

Amazing set!
Love the use of textures and effects
your compositions are outstanding!!!
Love your style amazing set here:
love the complex of: 11,19,11,36!!
you kill the theme!

[tturners.livejournal.com]

to be completely honest i always find myself speechless when i look at your icons!
they're just. so good. you are so skilled i am in awe – every single icon is a work of art [indiana jones' voice] it belongs in a museum. ♥
i'm sorry this comment will be rather long but i need to drop a line for EVERY piece because i'm incapable of choosing favourites :o so here we go!
1. the text placement is super clever, you hid his eyes and made the result even more mysterious
2. magnificent composition, the blending is exceptional and i love how each level is very well balanced in tones, because overall it creates a super nice contrast
3. HONESTLY. this sort of merging of two caps is one of the most difficult techniques e v e r and you manage to make it look effortlessly cool :D
4. the shadowing on clara's face WOW A+ INCREDIBLE
5. me, obsessed with silhouettes + blendings: i'm fine, like, this is very pretty [sobbing]
6. yes dorian!!!!!! i love you for always including him whenever you can &heart; the blocking is gorgeous and the b&w doesn't lose depth in comparison with the coloured version (needless to say i adore both versions)
7. i'm throwing my computer out of the window, this is a masterpiece BYE (your text placement here is so so so so beautiful and creative)
8. ahhhhh super close up!!! YES PLEASE AND THANKS! it's so emotional and delicate and also positively creepy in a way? it tells a story, you perfectly captured the noir vibe in such a simple way wow!! hashtag BLESS
9. power to grunge icons – lovelovelove how atmospheric this icon looks (also romantic?? i have no idea what's going on in the scene but the soft adorable vibes are there UGH ME LIKEY)
10. is this a movie poster? this should be a movie poster, the composition is exceptional and i love the way you used lights and shadows and the b&w tone is flawless
11. the tiny v big text opposition is on point, it also matches the show you chose!
12. excellent cropping and text placement! it's a fun icon and again the b&w doesn't sacrifice the depth in opposition with the coloured version
13. the epitome of mystery!!! excellent contrast between background/subject, you make sherlock stand out in a very clever and subtle way (you're so talented!!!!!)
14. eye-catching composition, also can i say this looks extra classy and old hollywood? 11/10
15. love how complex this looks in its simplicity and your text once again is striking! love the way you combine different fonts
16. spacious crop which is still close... oh my goodness... wonderful super wonderful (is that even a description? who knows)
17. perfection. the noise gives the crop and overall result an intriguing look
18. fantastic use of negative space plus magnificent blending once again! love that you added the text as well, and love how the overall complex result doesn't look crowded
19. STUNNING. the use of textures is awesome!
20. wowowow that dramatic lighting!!